Save. Plan. Retire.

small basket full of change save plan retire

Fixed Annuity vs CD Pros and Cons: (2023)

small basket full of change save plan retire

Before making the choice between investing in an fixed annuity vs CD, take time to consider your financial goals. If you desire higher potential payouts with lower interest rates, an annuity might be best.

However, if you are nearing or entering retirement and looking for tax deferral and higher returns on savings products such as bank CDs.

AspectFixed AnnuitiesCertificates of Deposit (CDs)
DefinitionInsurance-based contract that provides a guaranteed income stream for a specified periodTime deposit with a fixed interest rate and maturity period
ProsGuaranteed income, tax-deferred growth, potential for higher returns, lifetime income optionsStable returns, FDIC insurance, low-risk investment, predictable earnings
ConsLimited liquidity, potential surrender charges, potential inflation risk, dependence on insurer’s stabilityLow interest rates, penalties for early withdrawal, limited growth potential
Interest RatesVary based on market conditions, insurer’s rates, and contract termsFixed interest rate determined at the time of purchase
Risk and SafetyDependent on the insurer’s financial strength and stabilityFDIC-insured up to certain limits, lower risk investment
Tax ConsiderationsTax-deferred growth, potential for tax-free withdrawalsTaxable interest income
Liquidity and AccessLimited liquidity, potential surrender charges, withdrawal restrictionsLimited liquidity, penalties for early withdrawal, maturity dates
Suitability and PurposeRetirement income, long-term savings, guaranteed income streamShort-term savings, low-risk investment, capital preservation


Fixed annuities offer many retirees the security of consistent income during an agreed upon timeframe – up until death itself, in some cases. This feature makes fixed annuities particularly appealing as life expectancies continue to increase.

Fixed annuities also boast higher interest rates than bank CDs due to being insurance products backed by financial strength of the insurance provider offering them.

Fixed annuities do have certain drawbacks that investors must be wary of, such as incurring surrender charges similar to CDs if an account is closed before its agreed-upon period has passed.

Another potential drawback is that, should an investor select single-life payout options and then pass away shortly thereafter, their spouse or beneficiaries won’t receive payments from the insurance company. Therefore, when choosing fixed annuities for savings purposes it’s wise to opt for joint-and-survivor or period-certain payout options as these are more obligated to continue paying out benefits after death.

Fixed Annuities: Pros and Cons

Fixed annuities are popular choices among individuals looking to secure a reliable source of retirement income that won’t fluctuate with stock market fluctuations. Furthermore, fixed annuities provide steady payments throughout your retirement years which makes them attractive investment choices.

An insurance company manages an annuity’s principal investment and pays out guaranteed interest at a set interest rate for an agreed-upon term, so you can name a beneficiary to receive its full value at contract end. Withdrawals may be made within its penalty-free withdrawal period but any earnings taken out must pay taxes accordingly.

Investors considering fixed annuities should consult a certified financial professional to help determine whether this type of account fits with their investment goals and needs. Research the company carefully to make sure it has an established track record, while considering your state guaranty association which protects depositors should an insurer go out of business.

Certificates of Deposit CDs: Pros and Cons

CDs offer savers looking for safe investments that offer guaranteed rates of return a sound investment option. CDs can help savers meet specific goals like home downpayment or vacation expenses or longer-term ones like retirement.

Financial investments often offer higher interest rates than savings accounts and the compounded interest they accumulate helps their balance grow more quickly than regular savings accounts would. Unfortunately, however, they usually come with set terms and early withdrawal penalties that limit how quickly you can withdraw your savings from them.

Early withdrawal penalties of CDs can quickly wipe away your earnings, often even leading to the loss of principal. One effective strategy to mitigate this risk is known as laddering; this involves spreading out your funds among several CDs with different terms and maturity dates in order to reduce penalties.

One of the major drawbacks to CDs is their limited liquidity, making it more difficult to access funds if unexpected expenses or circumstances arise that require you to access them quickly.

Comparison of Returns and Interest Rates

With CDs, your money can be invested for a set period and the principal plus interest will be returned at its conclusion. Meanwhile, fixed annuities provide guaranteed income for either a specific time period or even lifetime income.

Fixed annuities offer one major advantage over traditional savings vehicles: earnings are tax deferred until withdrawal. This can make an enormous difference in your returns over time.

Fixed annuities offer another advantage over other investments: They’re backed by the government, making them safer than other options such as bank CDs which do not offer federal protection. This security advantage has become especially relevant following bank failures like Silicon Valley Bank and Signature Bank in recent months. Furthermore, most fixed annuities purchase government treasuries; therefore in order for your funds to be lost through them you would first have to see an insurance company default on their debt which would then cause your money loss as opposed to bank CDs which don’t afford federal protection against loss.

Risk Factors and Safety

Investment in a fixed annuity ensures you know exactly how much income will come your way annually – helping to plan for retirement income without being affected by stock market fluctuations or interest rate changes.

Fixed annuities offer another feature that may make them attractive: you can select to receive payments for a specified period, known as “period certain”. This feature ensures your beneficiaries will continue receiving income payments if you pass away during this timeframe.

Many annuities also contain surrender charges that apply if you withdraw funds early from your account, which can significantly lower your total return.

As early withdrawal from an annuity is subject to IRS taxes, it’s essential that your retirement planning options take your investment goals and tax situation into account before purchasing an annuity. For assistance in exploring your retirement planning strategies contact a financial professional and learn about annuities and CDs together – with their help, you may discover the ideal solution that fits both your individual needs and goals.

Tax Considerations and Benefits

Annuities are an alternative retirement savings vehicle that provide a guaranteed rate of interest, often recommended for those looking to avoid market volatility but who aren’t quite ready to dive headfirst into equities yet.

An annuity provides its owners with another tax advantage by deferring taxes until receiving income payments from their annuity contract. In other words, earnings will only be taxed once income payments begin arriving and not before.

However, early withdrawal can result in income taxes and penalties; to protect yourself against this scenario it’s essential to thoroughly review each contract prior to investing.

Fixed annuities offer more than just income security: they also offer benefits like death benefits, spousal protection, guaranteed minimum payouts and flexible withdrawal options – but this may increase their total costs. Therefore, it is wise to invest with an exemplary insurance provider with high ratings by industry rating agencies.

Liquidity and Accessibility

Fixed annuities provide low-risk savings with guaranteed rates of return, similar to CDs; however, fixed annuities offer additional advantages that make them an excellent choice for retirees.

Fixed annuities offer many advantages to help protect you against outliving your income, by dispersing payments over an agreed-upon time frame that suits your specific financial requirements.

Fixed annuities are protected by state guaranty funds up to their respective statutory limits, so your money is safe if an insurance company declares bankruptcy or becomes insolvent.

Fixed annuities offer another key benefit of fixed annuities: higher interest rates than bank CDs due to tax-deferred earnings versus ordinary income for CD withdrawals. Your financial professional can assist in understanding more clearly the differences between annuities and CDs as well as choosing suitable investments that best meet your financial goals and circumstances.


Bank CDs are a safe, low-risk investment that offers guaranteed returns over an agreed-upon time and are insured up to $250,000. But early withdrawal penalties and limited opportunities for further growth make fixed annuities more appealing; annuities offer tax deferral of interest earned, potential lifetime income streams and could help make up your portfolio’s monthly income stream. You can use a CD vs annuity calculator to compare these two investments and find which suits you best.

But CDs and fixed annuities both face potential losses during market downturns. Both investments also present purchasing power risk when their returns don’t keep pace with inflation; one way to address this issue is adding a cost of living adjustment rider onto your contract or investing in an index annuity instead which doesn’t guarantee returns, instead earning interest based on movements within an underlying financial benchmark.






Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.